Turbine Settles Treehouse Avatar Technologies Lawsuit

Turbine has settled a lawsuit brought by little-known company Treehouse Avatar Technologies for infringing on US Patent 8,180,858. Specifically, they were accused of using a  ”method and system For presenting data over a network based on network user choices and collecting real-time data related to said choices”. As a part of the agreement, pending litigation between Treehouse Avatar Technologies and Turbine will be dropped. This entire situation has been very strange from the start. Let’s put aside for now that “presenting data over a network based on network user choices and collecting real-time data related to said choices”  is written so broadly as to describe half of what happens on the Internet (ever gotten an online insurance quote?). It takes very little research to come to the following conclusions:

  • Treehouse Avatar Technologies is owned by Wi-LAN Inc., which describes itself as “An IP licensing company built on a rich history of innovation”. In other words, they make money by looking for people to sue.
  • Treehouse Avatar Technologies sent threatening letters to several small game development companies earlier this year for the same alleged infringement.
  • Treehouse Avatar Technologies has not proceeded with litigation against the smaller companies, where a settlement would likely not be as large, nor have they filed suit against any huge software developers such as Sony, Bllizzard or Turbine parent company Warner Brothers, where lawyers are more a-plenty.
  • The patent in question was filed in 2012, while both games accused of infringement (DDO and LOTRO) were launched several years prior.

It would appear (to this non-lawyer, anyway) that Turbine was the victim of a broken US patent system and chose to settle rather than let the lawsuit carry on. I am a little curious as to why WB did not chose to fight this harder, being that it could encourage other holders of broad technology patents to bring forth litigation, but perhaps they were somewhat handcuffed by not being specifically named in the lawsuit.

Braxwolf Stormchaser

Bookmark and Share


  1. Avatar of Draculetta

    This was nothing but a Patent Troll.. I can’t believe they did not fight this….

  2. Avatar of Zyngor

    It’s like the entirety of a GLFF channel decided to start a business venture…

  3. Avatar of The Dwarrow Scholar

    Indeed (if this is patent troll), I would have hoped that WB-lawyer-army would have taken these fellas apart. Guessing there is a lot more to it perhaps.

  4. Avatar of Tsu

    Off the cuff…

    These patent trolls do actually buy up huge amounts of patent rights and sometimes they actually do manage to land a hit…the lawyers(WB) cannot be certain of a successful defence…so settle…

    A shame really as these trolls need a good kicking…

    patent law in US needs a major reform: http://www.economist.com/node/18389167

  5. Avatar of Tsu

    Another newer related article with outline:

    ‘Whether this sort of thing is good for consumers, or will encourage more Americans to invent things, is not patently obvious.’

    Why I read the Economist!


    Lets have a TROLL hunting session in Trollshaws to celebrate!

  6. Avatar of Ethelros

    Can’t say I’m surprised actually. In cases like this it can be more expensive in the end to fight them than it is to settle. Which is exactly what these people rely on.


  1. LOTRO Players News Episode 23: Cyber Braxwood | LOTRO Players - […] Turbine Settles Lawsuit […]
  2. If Congress can’t stop patent trolls, Article One hopes crowd-sourced funding and research can — Tech News and Analysis - […] month, the troll bullied Turbine Inc, which makes games like Dungeons & Dragons Online, into a settlement. Now, the […]
  3. If Congress can’t stop patent trolls, Article One hopes crowd-sourced funding and research can | Tech Auntie - […] month, the troll bullied Turbine Inc, which makes games like Dungeons & Dragons Online, into a settlement. Now, the …
  4. Operation Ninja S.T.A.R. – Help fight patent trolls – ipstrategy.com - […] against numerous startups who can’t afford to fight.  In fact, one of them, Turbine Inc, just settled for an …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>